Doctor is now an outsourced contractor

2 April 2015

 

GST IN HEALTHCARE

THE Goods and Services Tax comes into effect today. Most people, including me, are prepared to comply with this new taxation system on our purchases of goods and services. But please allow me to share my musings from the viewpoint of a long-serving medical professional, who has believed over the years that he is a core provider of healthcare.

There has been much debate and confusion regarding the implementation of GST in private healthcare, but not much of this has occurred in other sectors. Clearly, healthcare is a special service not easily equated to other services or goods.

Healthcare touches the basic necessity of a person’s existence — his life. How did I, like others, begin to get confused by the decisions and statements regarding the implementation of GST in private hospitals, including the one I am serving at? The initial pronouncement by the authorities was that healthcare was GST-free.

Then came the technical jargon created by writers of GST. Terms such as “healthcare providers”, “outsourced contractors”, “standard-rated” and “zero-rated” came into play. As I am not employed by the hospital, I am now classified as an “outsourced contractor” because I am not registered as a healthcare provider under the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act. Only my hospital is.

As an outsourced contractor, I am standard-rated, and all my services are taxable with GST. The hospital’s services are GST free and patients do not have to pay GST on most services provided by the hospital. Much of the controversy has arisen because, initially, it was thought that as outsourced contractors, doctors would be providing service to hospitals that had contracted them and if so, these hospitals had to pay GST on the payments they made to doctors.

Earlier statements from the authorities appeared to imply that. In some situations, doctors came to believe that they had to bear at least part of the GST to be paid, if this was the GST arrangement. Now, it is decided that doctors are not healthcare providers (in the eyes of GST law), instead, they are outsourced contractors (a humbling and emasculating pronouncement, I must say). These doctors are to collect GST from patients and not from their hospitals.

I am now resigned to this. The only thing is that a situation has been created where an entity called a hospital has been divorced (conceptually, at least) from individuals, who provide the main healthcare service. We used to think that we were an entity together as the hospital needed us to be with them to get licensed, that is, we were their flesh and bones. In reality, almost all private hospitals do not employ their specialists and their specialists are almost all outsourced contractors by current definition. So, what healthcare services do private hospitals provide? They provide beds and rooms, facilities for care, such as operation theatres and intensive care units, pharmacy, nursing, physiotherapy, linen and kitchen services.

By GST, these constitute healthcare provision and are mainly non-taxable. Of course, if the hospitals employ their specialists, which is rare, the services of these specialists would also be GST-free. Although my patients and I know that I am the core provider of healthcare, it is fait accompli that I am a mere outsourced contractor as of today.

I am prepared to include the six per cent in my bill to patients, with the help of my hospital. The facts appear to be clearer and the experts have ready-made answers. The technical aspects of GST are non-debatable any more. The experts are doing it right. But as a human blessed with ideas of right and wrong, my mind cannot stop asking questions. Please examine the following scenarios.

SCENARIO 1: A businessman wants to celebrate his success. He buys a RM30,000 watch. He happily pays for the watch plus the six per cent tax.

SCENARIO 2: A man riding a motorbike gets knocked down by a lorry, and suffers head injury and multiple fractures and a lung collapse. He is taken by ambulance to the nearest hospital, which is a private one. He requires multiple surgeries, intensive care and expensive medication. He survives his ordeal and is discharged after a month’s stay at the hospital. His doctors’ fees come to RM30,000 out of a total fee of RM100,000. He is supported by his employers for a maximum of RM25,000, which is divided proportionately between the hospital and doctors. He has to pay six per cent on the remaining doctors’ fees and unapproved medication. Of course, he does not have to pay GST on his room, food, nursing and other services provided by the hospital.

SCENARIO 3: A 2-year-old boy from a poor family requires a lifesaving heart surgery provided only by an expert surgeon in a private hospital. Your newspaper helps to raise money for this. This child is taxed six per cent on the expert’s fees, which thankfully, has been reduced by this charitable specialist. The family is grateful to the specialist for saving the child’s life. In all three scenarios, all consumers have to pay GST on their goods or services. But some pertinent philosophical and ethical questions to ask are: is seeking pleasure equivalent to seeking treatment for life and limb? Are they equally taxable? If some aspects of healthcare are taxable, why choose the very soul of it, that is, the doctors’ life-saving work and not the peripherals, such as rooms and food? Are we doing the right thing? Not everyone who seeks private healthcare has the means. A health issue is a personal, family and societal calamity. Beyond the ringgit and sen, and the technicalities of the implementation of GST, there are interesting but serious ethical and philosophical issues to be debated. Where then are our ethicists and thinkers? I need their assurance that I am part of an ethically flawless and highly necessary endeavour for our country’s wellbeing. I am all for my country’s wellbeing, of course. I am also all for my patients’ wellbeing. All said and done, from today, I will have to get used to existing in two contradicting worlds governed by two laws. I am a registered doctor (healthcare provider) under the Medical Act but an outsourced contractor (not a healthcare provider) under GST. I will continue to provide the best care to my dear patients. And by writing to you, I hope I will be relieved of a mental burden not easily understood by those not passionately involved in healthcare.

Professor Datuk Dr Azizi Omar,

Petaling Jaya, Selangor

 

Originally published in nst.com.my
http://www.nst.com.my/node/79083

 

Go Back

Events

Date: 25 Nov 2017
Insight Into Clinical Radiology
Details

 

Date: 8 Oct 2017
Doctors' Day Celebration 2017
Details

 

Date: 16 & 17 Sep 2017
1st FPMPAM/IPH Annual Scientific Convention
Announcement || Souvenir Programme

 

Date: 24 - 26 Aug 2017
Kuala Lumpur International Forum on Quality and Safety in Healthcare 2017
Website

 

Date: 8 & 9 Sep 2017
Nursing Conference 7.0 / Training Course for Clinic Personnel 9.0
Full details || Report

 

Announcements

16 Aug 2016
REPORT: 6th Nursing Conference
Read >>

21 Sep 2015

3 Ways to Let Your Doctor Know, You Care
Read >>

8 Sep 2015

MedicAlert®
Flyer >>

28 Aug 2015

REPORT: 5th Nursing Conference
Read >>

20 Aug 2015

5 Things You Did Not Know About Doctors’ Day
Read >>

2 April 2015

List of zero-rated drugs under GST
Download >>

3 March 2015

Draft Letter for Pengecualian dari pendaftaran GST
Download >>

12 Feb 2015

In Memory - Tuan Guru Dato' Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat
More >>


Recent Events

Date: 21-23 July 2017
10th ASEAN & 7th Perak Health Conference on Primary Health Care
Announcement

 

Date: 7 May 2017
Management of UTI in Primary Care Setting
Announcement

Date: 4 Dec 2016
PMPS Day Trip
Announcement

 

Date: 9 Oct 2016
Doctors' Day 2016
Registration Form | Sponsorship Form

Date: 5-7 Aug 2016
9th NatCAM and AGM of the Addiction Medicine Association Malaysia
Flyer | Registration Form | Souvenir Programme

 

10-12 Nov 2016
2nd FPMPAM Sabah Medical Camp
Venue: Sabah
More >>

 

9-10 Jan 2016
PMPS Family Day
Venue: Pangkor Island
More >>

24 Oct 2015
Psoriasis - Skin & Beyond
Venue: Fraser Hotel & Residences
More >>


8 Nov 2015
Resolution In Medico-Legal Disputes
Venue: Kuala Lumpur Regional Centre for Arbitration (KLRCA)
More >>

 

10 Oct 2015
Doctors' Day
Venue: Bayview Beach Hotel, Batu Ferringhi, Penang
More >>

 

30 July 2015
Mediation of Medico-Legal Disputes: Is It A Viable Alternative?
Venue: Kuala Lumpur Regional Centre for Arbitration (KLRCA)
More >>

24-26 April 2015
9th ASEAN Conference on Primary Health Care
Theme: Primary Care for all Ages
Venue: Kinta Riverfront Hotel & Suites, Ipoh, Perak, Malaysia
More >>

18-19 April 2015
PMPASKL ASC 2015
Theme: Clinics in Primary Care
Venue: Dorsett Grand Subang, Subang Jaya, Selangor.
More >>

10 Oct 2014
Doctor's Day
Details >>.

16-18 May 2014
8th NatCAM 2014
The 8th NatCAM 2014 from 16 to 18 May 2014 was organized by the Addition Medicine Association of Malaysia and co-hosted by the FPMPAM at the Pullman Hotel, Kuala Lumpur. Continue >>.

9 & 10 May 2014
The 2nd Menarini Primary Care Symposium, 2014
The 2nd Menarini Primary Care Symposium 2014 was attended by 70 participants on 9 & 10 May 2014 and held at the Lexis Hotel at Port Dickson, Malaysia. Continue >>

8 May 2014
Citizen’s Action in Response to Emergencies (CARE) Interview with RTM
On 8 May, Dr Steven Chow and CARE trainers from our partner St John’s Ambulance, Malaysia (SJAM) presented to RTM on the importance of AEDs for saving lives in the event of a cardiac arrest. Continue >>

19 & 20 April 2014
PMPASKL Annual Scientific Meeting, 2014
The Private Medical Practitioners’ Association of Selangor and Kuala Lumpur (PMPASKL), the KL and Selangor member society of the Federation, convened its 54th AGM and Scientific Conference on 19 & 20 April 2014 at Holiday Inn, Kuala Lumpur. Continue >>

 

Latest Newsletter


go to newsletter section

 

Latest newsletter of Perak Medical Practitioners' Society
Click here >>

 

 

Resources / Links

Joint Integrated Healthcare Committee (JIHC) Term Sheet
Click here >>

 

Joint Integrated Healthcare Committee (JIHC) Terms of Reference
Click here >>

 

National Pharmaceutical Regulatory Agency
Click here >>

 

NPRA: Reporting medicinal problems
Click here >>

 

Makluman Kontraindikasi Penggunaan Ubat Yang Mengandungi Codeine Untuk Kanak-Kanak Beumur Bawah 12 Tahun Dan Ibu Yang Menyusu Susulan Risiko Respiratory Depression
Click here >>

 

Peringatan: Langkah-Langkah Pengurangan Risiko Bagi Kesan Advers Kulit Tang Serius Susulan Penggunaan Allopurinol
Click here >>

 

VALPROATE
Guide for HCP >>
Patient Information >>
Sodium Valproate (Guide for HCP) >>

 

NDST REport 2011
Click here >>

 

Garis Panduan Pemantauan Keselamatan Produk ESAs dan Pelaporan Kesan Advers PRCA
Click here >>

 

Report On Suspected Adverse Drug Reactions
Click here >>

 

MADRAC KE 146 - Traditional Medicine found Adulterated
Read >>

BPFK website: Cancellation of Registered Traditional Products / Notified Cosmetics
Read >>


Pharmacy Services Division: List of Adulterated Products
Read >>

 

Pharmacy Services Division: Press Releases
Read >>